The Absolute Best Ice Cream in Fairfax VA [Updated 2025]

Whether you're a lifelong local or just passing through, there's something undeniably magical about finding that perfect scoop. After diving into the delicious world of ice cream, I’ve narrowed down my top 12 spots in Fairfax that are sure to tickle your taste buds and cool you down on those hot summer days.

With countless flavors, quirky toppings, and unique atmospheres, I’ve tasted my way through each one, focusing on what makes each place special. Trust me, I’ve savored every spoonful, so you can skip the guesswork and dive straight into pure creamy bliss. Ready to discover your new favorite treat? Let’s scoop into it!

Sugar Mama's Ice Cream

Highlights
Best ice cream and Italian ice
Unique Indian flavor options
Cute mom-and-pop café vibe
Original base flavors available
Educative and friendly owner

Sugar Mama's Ice Cream in Fairfax, VA, is a delightful haven for ice cream enthusiasts like me. As soon as I stepped inside, the cute mom-and-pop café vibe enveloped me, instantly making it feel like home. The friendly owner, who is both educative and passionate, shared exciting tales about their unique flavors, including some exotic Indian options that caught my attention.

I decided to indulge in a scoop of their original base flavors, which were nothing short of divine. Each bite revealed a creamy richness that felt luxurious on my palate. I was especially fascinated by the Italian ice they offer, a refreshing departure from traditional ice cream that’s perfect for those warm Fairfax days.

What truly sets Sugar Mama’s apart is the creative twist they put on flavors, introducing intriguing combinations that I couldn't resist trying. Overall, my visit was a delightful journey for my taste buds, leaving me eager to return for more tasty adventures. If you're looking for the best ice cream in Fairfax, I wholeheartedly recommend Sugar Mama's—it's a sweet treat that truly delivers in flavor and charm!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Waldorf MD.

Toby’s Handmade Ice Cream

Highlights
Creamy texture
Convenient location
Limited flavor options
Subpar customer service
Stale waffle cones

Toby’s Handmade Ice Cream in Fairfax, VA, is a cozy little spot that promises a delightful escape on a warm day. The moment I stepped in, I was greeted by the tempting aroma of freshly made ice cream. I decided to indulge in a classic scoop of their vanilla, known for its creamy texture. And let me tell you, it was every bit as luscious as I had hoped! The ice cream seemed to melt effortlessly, creating a smooth sensation upon my palate.

However, I did notice that the flavor options were somewhat limited, which left me yearning for more adventurous choices. While I appreciated the quality, the lack of variety made my decision a tad less exciting. Additionally, the stale waffle cones were a disappointment; they lacked the crispness that I personally adore in a cone.

The location is undoubtedly convenient, but my experience was somewhat dampened by the subpar customer service. I hoped for a friendly chat about flavors, but it felt a bit rushed instead. Overall, Toby’s Handmade Ice Cream had its highlights, but it still left room for improvement. It’s a sweet spot worth a visit, but perhaps not the absolute best in Fairfax VA!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Chinatown Washington.

Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard

Highlights
Friendly ice cream options
Variety of flavors available
Family-friendly atmosphere
Convenient closing hours
Popular local chain

Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard in Fairfax VA is a delightful spot that truly embodies the spirit of summer. As I approached the charming little shop, the captivating variety of flavors already caught my eye, promising a delightful adventure for my taste buds. The moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by the friendly staff, who were happy to share recommendations and samples. Their enthusiasm is infectious!

I decided to indulge in a scoop of their signature frozen custard—delightfully creamy and rich, it melted effortlessly on my tongue. With flavors ranging from classic vanilla to exotic mango, there’s something for everyone here. And let’s not forget the Italian ice—a refreshing and vibrant choice that pairs perfectly with the custard.

The ambiance at Rita's is family-friendly, making it an ideal spot for an outing with loved ones. I appreciated the convenient closing hours, allowing me to satisfy my cravings even after dinner. If you’re hunting for a sweet escape in Fairfax, Rita's delivers not just ice cream, but an experience filled with joy and laughter. All in all, this charming local chain is a must-visit for anyone looking to cool off with a delightful treat!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Alexandria VA.

Bruster's Real Ice Cream

Highlights
Efficient and polite staff
Quick service
Dairy-free options available
Great corner location
Generous toppings

When I stepped into Bruster’s Real Ice Cream, I was immediately struck by the friendly atmosphere and the efficient staff ready to serve. It felt like a warm invitation to dive headfirst into a world of delightful flavors. One thing that stood out was the quick service; I hardly had time to pick my flavor before it was my turn!

I decided to try their rich chocolate fudge—a classic that never disappoints. The texture was incredibly creamy, and the flavor was intensely chocolatey without being overwhelming. And for those who might steer clear of dairy, Bruster's offers dairy-free options. It’s nice to see a shop catering to all ice cream lovers!

Located conveniently at a bustling corner, it’s perfect for a sweet break during a day out or after a meal. I also couldn't resist piling on some of their generous toppings, each adding a delightful crunch to my smooth ice cream experience. Whether you are a first-timer or a regular, Bruster’s Real Ice Cream is seriously a must-visit when you’re in Fairfax! Don’t miss out on this fantastic ice cream experience!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Germantown MD.

Cold Stone Creamery

Highlights
Late-night hours
Exceptional service
Rich, creamy ice cream
Fun mixing experience
Generous portions

Upon entering Cold Stone Creamery, I was immediately greeted by a delightful symphony of flavors and an inviting atmosphere. Their late-night hours meant I could indulge my sweet tooth well into the evening, which is always a treat! The exceptional service made the experience even sweeter, as the staff was friendly and eager to help me navigate their extensive menu.

I opted for their signature rich and creamy ice cream, blended on a frozen granite stone right before my eyes. The fun mixing experience allowed me to customize my creation with unlimited toppings, and trust me—I went all out! Each scoop was generously portioned, giving me plenty to savor.

Whether you're a fan of classic flavors or adventurous combinations, Cold Stone delivers a burst of joy in every bite. Their vibrant atmosphere combined with the theater of mixing your ice cream right in front of you makes for a truly delightful experience. If you’re in Fairfax, I wholeheartedly recommend stopping by Cold Stone Creamery to satisfy your ice cream cravings. You won't be disappointed—this place is a true gem in the world of frozen treats!

You might also want to check out the best brunch in Georgetown.

Lil City Creamery

Highlights
Distinctive, tasty ice creams
Quirky shop with unique items
Affordable, high-quality flavors
Great outdoor seating options
Favorite among local ice cream lovers

Lil City Creamery is a delightful gem in Fairfax, VA that truly captures the essence of local charm and high-quality ice cream. Upon stepping into the shop, I was greeted by a quirky atmosphere filled with vibrant art and whimsical decor that instantly brought a smile to my face.

The menu features a distinctive array of flavors, each one crafted to tell its own delicious story. I couldn’t resist trying the Salted Caramel Pretzel — a stunning contrast of sweet and salty that danced on my taste buds. The creaminess was just divine, making each bite a creamy embrace. What I especially appreciated was the affordability; indulging in such high-quality ice cream didn’t come with a hefty price tag!

Outdoor seating added to the experience, allowing me to enjoy my treat while basking in the sun, surrounded by fellow ice cream lovers. Lil City Creamery has certainly become an instant favorite in the community. If you're looking to satisfy your sweet tooth with unique flavors in a lively setting, this little slice of paradise should be at the top of your list! You won’t regret it.

You might also want to check out the best breakfast in Arlington VA.

Dolcezza Gelato & Coffee

Highlights
Delicious gelato flavors
High-quality coffee
Knowledgeable barista
Pistachio & dark chocolate
Slightly pricey, worth it

Stepping into Dolcezza Gelato & Coffee felt like entering a delightful dreamscape of flavors! The moment I approached the counter, I was met with an impressive array of gelato flavors, each beckoning me to indulge. As a fan of unique combinations, I couldn’t resist trying their pistachio and dark chocolate gelato. The pistachio was brilliantly creamy, with a robust nutty flavor that danced beautifully on my palate. Meanwhile, the dark chocolate held an exquisite richness—each bite was a decadent treat!

As if the gelato weren’t enough, their high-quality coffee made for a perfect accompaniment. I was greeted by a wonderfully knowledgeable barista who expertly guided me through their coffee options, enhancing my dessert experience.

While Dolcezza may be slightly on the pricier side, I assure you that the quality and craftsmanship absolutely justify the splurge. This gem in Fairfax is not just a stop for gelato; it's an experience for your taste buds. Whether you're craving creamy gelato or a finely brewed coffee, you owe it to yourself to visit Dolcezza. 🍦☕

You might also want to check out the best brunch in Arlington VA.

Woody's Ice Cream

Woody's Ice Cream in Fairfax, VA, is a delightful stop for any ice cream lover. The moment I stepped inside, the aroma of freshly made waffle cones enveloped me, instantly elevating my mood. I dove into their signature cake batter flavor, a decadent blend that felt like a warm hug on a spoon. The creaminess was exceptional, with specks of real cake that added a playful texture. The friendly staff added to the charm, serving up smiles along with scoops. If you’re looking for a sweet escape, Woody’s is a must-visit—it’s a whimsical treat that deserves a spot on your dessert radar! 🍦

You might also want to check out the best breakfast in Alexandria VA.

Sweet Berry

During my delightful visit to Sweet Berry in Fairfax VA, I was greeted by a vibrant atmosphere and the irresistible aroma of freshly made waffle cones. Their extensive menu offers something for everyone, but I couldn’t resist trying the Salted Caramel Swirl—a velvety blend that danced between sweet and savory with every spoonful. The toppings were plentiful, and the friendly staff made me feel right at home. It's a perfect spot for ice cream lovers looking for unique flavors and a cozy vibe. I left with a big smile and a cone in hand, ready to return for more!

You might also want to check out the best cupcakes in Washington.

Mimi's Handmade Ice Cream

Mimi's Handmade Ice Cream is a delightful gem in Fairfax, VA. As I stepped in, the sweet and creamy perfume of freshly churned ice cream wrapped around me like a warm hug. Each scoop is a tantalizing masterpiece! I savored the Salted Caramel, which struck the perfect balance between sweet and salty, while the Chocolate Hazelnut was decadently rich and luscious. The textures were velvety, and every bite felt indulgent. Plus, the cheerful staff added to the charming atmosphere! For anyone seeking a flavor adventure, Mimi's is a must-visit. Scoop up some happiness today!

You might also want to check out the best burger in Alexandria VA.

Gâteau MJ Dessert Shop

Stepping into Gâteau MJ Dessert Shop is like entering a whimsical dessert wonderland! I was immediately captivated by their vibrant selection of artisanal ice creams. The salted caramel flavor was a divine balance of sweet and savory, while the lavender honey offered an unexpected floral twist that danced on my palate. Each scoop is rich and creamy, melting effortlessly into a symphony of taste. The cozy atmosphere and friendly staff made my visit even sweeter. If you find yourself in Fairfax searching for a treat that elevates your dessert game, make sure to stop by Gâteau MJ—you won’t regret it!

You might also want to check out the best cookies in Washington.

La Moo Creamery

My visit to La Moo Creamery was an absolute delight! The moment I stepped inside, the whimsical decor made me feel like a kid again. I indulged in their rich salted caramel, which was perfectly balanced—sweet with a delightful salty twist. The staff was incredibly friendly, eager to share their favorites. I also couldn’t resist trying the lavender honey, which was both refreshing and unique. With options like these, it's no wonder La Moo is a beloved local gem. If you're searching for artisan ice cream that sparks joy, make sure to stop by and treat yourself!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Gaithersburg MD.